I was less than impressed with this one and rated it 3 stars too. Considering how much I’ve enjoyed the author’s other books, it was somewhat disappointing. I also 100% agree with you on the feeling that she wanted to cram as many of her political and social views into this story as she could. It felt awkwardly handled and out of place, especially when you think how other authors have managed to do the same thing more seamlessly.
I still plan on giving her other books a try but man did this one push my desire to read them as soon as possible a bit further.
Tell me about it… I had a feeling she was going to tackle those subjects one after the other without too much substance/originality. The moment she included the sexuality subject, she crossed the line and made me facepalm!
Great review Lashaan! I don’t think I’ve ever read a retelling, but it sounds like something I might enjoy! Maybe not this one though, as I usually find it quite hard to finish a book when I don’t like the protagonist or when his or her personality is very annoying…
Thanks, Juliette! There are so many YA retellings of classic fairytales out there, if you’re ever craving for those. I think anyone who wants to try the books by this author, they should check out her first books like Alice. But I definitely agree that such a protagonist is hard to tag along with! 😬
GAHHHH my gut is still working! I totally skipped this one and good thing. I’m sooooo sick of being preached to. And I’m sick and tired of characters I can’t back. 😉 Great Lashaan as always.
Ohhhhh dear… I am halfway through the book and I am a bit baffled… It’s my first by the author and she has had such a good reception I don’t know what I was expecting but… I am… this book confuses the frack out of me… for the reasons you have listed – I have highlighted bits based on your comments as well and … what age is she? The story reads like she’s a child but then there’s mention that she’s 20 and all that jazz and I feel disjointed as hell XD it reads fast though… and boy, oh boy, I can’t wait to start writing my review… kidding, it’ll be a tough one to write… sigh…
Hahahahaha I’m actually glad I wasn’t the only one. By the end of it, I was inclined to consider this YA, regardless of the “violence” in it. It’s also my first by the author but I’ll give her another chance by checking out Alice. I feel like she might have tried something new here by making it closer to “reality” compared to her other work. Hope you’ll have a less rocky ending though!
Well, that’s just it… The last 20% of the book was quite neat! So, now I am stuck on my rating, damn it 😀
But, like you, it was also my first Henry and I think I would also like to give Alice a chance. I never liked Peter Pan as a story so I doubt I will ever read the retelling of it…
I think this book is definitely not for me hahaha 😂 I have such a hard time reading books with annoying protagonists and I’m not sure I would enjoy retellings either 🤔 For me, if it’s not in the original story, then it’s something else and using the same characters only bothers me 😂 That being said, I never tried it so I might like it! Great review, Lashaan 😍
I know, right? There are a lot of obvious references throughout the book too. I mean… Red Riding Hood was explicitly mentioned within the story too… Talk about subtlety hahah
Bookidote 
Thank goodness for all the movies this generation watches. Now they can survive ANYTHING!
*super duper Superman eyeroll*
I’ve already seen some reviews for this book so I knew I’d be ragging on it no matter what you wrote 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahah if everyone started to get their tips and tricks from Hollywood movies, mankind will have quite the downfall!
I wouldn’t have recommended this to you even if I was tortured 😂 You’d have probably thrown it as fast as you picked it up 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was less than impressed with this one and rated it 3 stars too. Considering how much I’ve enjoyed the author’s other books, it was somewhat disappointing. I also 100% agree with you on the feeling that she wanted to cram as many of her political and social views into this story as she could. It felt awkwardly handled and out of place, especially when you think how other authors have managed to do the same thing more seamlessly.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I still plan on giving her other books a try but man did this one push my desire to read them as soon as possible a bit further.
Tell me about it… I had a feeling she was going to tackle those subjects one after the other without too much substance/originality. The moment she included the sexuality subject, she crossed the line and made me facepalm!
LikeLike
Fab review! I’ve only read really positive reviews for this so it’s really good to read yours to balance them out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Nicki! Yep, I had to share my honest opinion on it after all. It’s all about the target audience. 😂
LikeLike
Great review Lashaan! I don’t think I’ve ever read a retelling, but it sounds like something I might enjoy! Maybe not this one though, as I usually find it quite hard to finish a book when I don’t like the protagonist or when his or her personality is very annoying…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Juliette! There are so many YA retellings of classic fairytales out there, if you’re ever craving for those. I think anyone who wants to try the books by this author, they should check out her first books like Alice. But I definitely agree that such a protagonist is hard to tag along with! 😬
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve seen several mixed reviews about this one… And I’m not too into retellings/ fairytales/ etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe her other work would be a nice entry point for her horror retelling stuff but otherwise, I’m sure you have plenty to read already!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I do! Always!
LikeLiked by 1 person
GAHHHH my gut is still working! I totally skipped this one and good thing. I’m sooooo sick of being preached to. And I’m sick and tired of characters I can’t back. 😉 Great Lashaan as always.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahhah yes! It’s not a bad book but I think everyone should know what they’re getting theirselves into 😂 Thanks for reading, Dani! 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ohhhhh dear… I am halfway through the book and I am a bit baffled… It’s my first by the author and she has had such a good reception I don’t know what I was expecting but… I am… this book confuses the frack out of me… for the reasons you have listed – I have highlighted bits based on your comments as well and … what age is she? The story reads like she’s a child but then there’s mention that she’s 20 and all that jazz and I feel disjointed as hell XD it reads fast though… and boy, oh boy, I can’t wait to start writing my review… kidding, it’ll be a tough one to write… sigh…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahahaha I’m actually glad I wasn’t the only one. By the end of it, I was inclined to consider this YA, regardless of the “violence” in it. It’s also my first by the author but I’ll give her another chance by checking out Alice. I feel like she might have tried something new here by making it closer to “reality” compared to her other work. Hope you’ll have a less rocky ending though!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, that’s just it… The last 20% of the book was quite neat! So, now I am stuck on my rating, damn it 😀
But, like you, it was also my first Henry and I think I would also like to give Alice a chance. I never liked Peter Pan as a story so I doubt I will ever read the retelling of it…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think this book is definitely not for me hahaha 😂 I have such a hard time reading books with annoying protagonists and I’m not sure I would enjoy retellings either 🤔 For me, if it’s not in the original story, then it’s something else and using the same characters only bothers me 😂 That being said, I never tried it so I might like it! Great review, Lashaan 😍
LikeLike
Not for me especially if there’s preachy stuff in there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s never too intriguing when it’s preachy. 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lots of transformations including “the girl in red” becoming “red”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know, right? There are a lot of obvious references throughout the book too. I mean… Red Riding Hood was explicitly mentioned within the story too… Talk about subtlety hahah
LikeLike